How to Choose an Advertising Agency: A Checklist
You paid an agency for three months, received a beautiful deck, and saw almost no new customers. This story is common, and the cause is rarely "bad marketers". More often, the business never agreed on goals, reporting and access before the start. This guide explains how to choose an advertising agency: the fee models, what to ask at the first meeting, which signals should worry you, and when you do not need an agency at all.
First, decide whether you need an agency
The advertising market is growing. According to All-Ukrainian Advertising Coalition data cited by Forbes Ukraine, Ukraine's advertising and communications market grew by about 13% in 2025, to UAH 33.4 billion, with a 2026 forecast of UAH 37.3 billion. Large brands spend most of that money. A small business does not always need the same agency services as a national chain.
| Your situation | What fits |
|---|---|
| Several channels, a large budget, no in-house marketer | Full-service agency |
| One specialist channel, such as search ads | Niche agency or freelancer |
| One location, one district, a test budget | Self-service launch on a transparent platform |
| You have a marketer but lack creative capacity | Contractor for design or video only |
If you are in the third row, start with the guide on how to launch local advertising in Kyiv without an agency.
How an advertising agency makes money
The fee model shapes the contractor's incentives. Find it out before you discuss creative.
- Commission on budget. The agency earns a percentage of ad spend. A bigger budget means more income, so "raise your budget" is not always neutral advice.
- Fixed monthly fee (retainer). You know the amount in advance. Agree the scope of work, or a flat fee quickly turns into "we are busy with other clients".
- Media markup. The agency buys placement and resells it at a higher price. The markup often reaches 15–30%, and you cannot see it without the owner's price list.
- Pay for results. You pay per lead or sale. The model is attractive, but agree exactly what counts as a result and who counts it.
Run the numbers on a hypothetical example. You allocate UAH 30,000 per month and the agency takes 20%. Then UAH 6,000 goes to services and UAH 24,000 reaches the ads. That is fair if the UAH 6,000 buys strategy, creative and reporting. It is expensive if the contractor only forwarded your banner to a media owner.
10 questions for an advertising agency at the first meeting
- Who exactly will work on our project, and will that person attend meetings?
- Which metric do you propose as success for the first 30 days?
- How much of the budget goes to ads, and how much to services?
- Will we see the media owner's price list and the closing documents?
- Will the ad accounts be registered to our company?
- Who produces the creative, and how many revisions does the price include?
- How often do we receive a report, and what will it contain?
- Do you have a case with a business of our size, not only with large brands?
- What is the minimum contract term, and how do we end it?
- What would you advise us not to do?
The last question is revealing. A strong contractor names channels you do not need, even if that costs them part of the budget. Put points 3, 4, 5 and 9 in writing: see what to check in an advertising services contract.
Red flags
- A guarantee of "top positions" or an exact number of sales. Nobody controls the market, your competitors or how you handle leads.
- Ad accounts held by the agency. When the work ends, you lose the campaign history and the data.
- A report with impressions but no money. Reach without spend and leads explains nothing. Ask for cost per contact and cost per lead.
- A long contract with no test period. A year of commitment before the first result is a risk for a small business.
- A media plan with no explanation. Ask why these channels were chosen. To compare, build a simple media plan yourself.
- A deck instead of your problem. If the proposal has none of your numbers, you were shown a template.
How to compare several agencies
Give two or three contractors the same brief: goal, budget, district, timeline. Then score the answers in one table.
| Criterion | What to look for |
|---|---|
| Understanding of the task | Did they ask clarifying questions |
| Money transparency | Are services and media listed separately |
| Measurement | Did they name a metric and how to count it |
| Team | Do you know the person doing the work, not only the manager |
| Exit | Can you end the work without a penalty |
Start with a one-month test. It shows speed and communication quality better than any portfolio.
When a local business can advertise without an agency
An agency pays off when there is complexity to manage: many channels, cities and formats. For a coffee shop, salon, studio or service in one district, the task is often simpler: show a clear offer to people nearby. This is how HostAd works.
HostAd sells ad time on screens in Kyiv coffee shops and bars. The site currently lists 29 venues. The process is simple: you choose a venue on the map, upload a creative and pay online, with no proposals and no calls.
- You see the price before you book. The rate on a venue page is UAH 25 to 90 per second of airtime per month. A 15-second video costs UAH 375 to 1,350 per month for one screen.
- No quarterly contract. You can take one month as a test, then extend it.
- No agency markup. You see the screen owner's price and pay exactly that.
- A real location. Each venue page shows the address, an audience description and a reach estimate of 2,500 to 9,000 people per month. For example, look at Kava.li on Preobrazhenska Street.
This format does not replace an agency if you need a nationwide campaign or a new category launch. It does give you a clear test in your own district, and you can assess the result yourself with a QR code and the campaign report.
Quick checklist
- Write down one business goal and a budget.
- Decide whether there is complexity worth paying an agency for.
- If there is, send the same brief to two or three contractors.
- Ask the 10 questions and check the answers against the table.
- Fix access, reporting and exit terms in the contract.
- Start with a one-month test.
Want to see prices first, without an agency and without calls? Open the HostAd map, choose a venue in your district and compare the cost with the contractor's proposal.